Unexamined assumptions
Which beliefs are carrying the decision, and what evidence would change our minds?
Make the assumptions visible.THE DOUBT DIVIDEND / A WAY TO THINK
The consequences that matter most are often the ones nobody thought to ask about.
An evolving five-lens method for understanding assumptions, incentives and consequences before making important decisions.
THE PRINCIPLE
The point is not to question everything forever. It is to find the assumptions that matter, test them properly, and make a more defensible commitment.
Drawing on game theory, systems thinking, historical parallels and practical experience, the method looks beyond immediate benefits to the behaviors and risks a decision may create.
See the five-lens methodTHREE QUESTIONS TO ASK NEXT
Which beliefs are carrying the decision, and what evidence would change our minds?
Make the assumptions visible.What will people, organizations or AI agents do differently once the rules change?
Follow the changing behaviors.What happens after the first benefit arrives, and who experiences the consequences?
Follow the effects beyond the obvious.This is a developing intellectual method, not a claim of proven outcomes. Its questions are meant to improve reasoning, not replace evidence or judgment.
FOLLOW THE THINKING
Second-Order Questions, the first Consequences May Vary essay series, explores the older ideas, strategic games and modern dilemmas behind this approach.
Explore the essay series